With all the new theories popping up with the start of Season 2, creator/writer/executive producer Dan Erickson recently revealed that none of the Season 2 theories he’s seen so far are actually correct:
“I love all of them and some of them are kooky, but the show is kooky, so it makes sense. I would not say that I’ve seen anybody get it totally right. We are trying to lay down the seeds of where it’s ultimately going, and I do think that people notice that … But I don’t think that I’ve seen anything where I’m like, ‘Oh God, they got it. Time to leave the country and change my name.'”